Gabriel LaBelle Lorne Michaels Rachel Sennott Rosie Shuster Cooper Hoffman Dick Ebersol Dylan O'Brien Dan Aykroyd Cory Michael Smith Chevy Chase Lamorne Morris Garrett Morris Willem Dafoe David Tebet Ella Hunt Gilda Radner Emily Fairn Laraine Newman Matt Wood John Belushi Kim Matula Jane Curtin Tommy Dewey Michael O'Donoghue Andrew Barth Feldman Neil Levy Nicholas Braun Andy Kaufman / Jim Henson Kaia Gerber Jacqueline Carlin Catherine Curtin Joan Carbunkle Nicholas Podany Billy Crystal Corinne Britti Valri Bromfield Finn Wolfhard NBC Page J.K. Simmons Milton Berle Matthew Rhys George Carlin Taylor Gray Al Franken Leander Suleiman Anne Beatts Mcabe Gregg Tom Davis Kirsty Woodward Audrey Dickman Jon Batiste Billy Preston Naomi McPherson Janis Ian Brian Welch Don Pardo Tracy Letts Herb Sargent Paul Rust Paul Shaffer Josh Brener Alan Zweibel Brad Garrett Borscht Belt Comedian Rowan Joseph Jim Fox Billy Bryk Carl Ellen Boscov Mrs. Kaufman Justin Matthew Smith Joe Dicso Abraham Hsu Leo Yoshimura Parker Wierling Tom Schiller Presley Coley Barbara Gallagher James Logan Stew Sorrentino Robert Wuhl Dave Wilson Drew Scheid Bob Pook Martin Garner Video Engineer Jeff Pope Scotty Schachter John Ross Crane Op Jeff Witzke Johnny Carson (voice)