Oscar Isaac Jesus Christ (voice) Kenneth Branagh Charles Dickens (voice) Uma Thurman Catherine Dickens (voice) Pierce Brosnan Pontius Pilate (voice) Roman Griffin Davis Walter Dickens (voice) Forest Whitaker Peter (voice) Ben Kingsley High Priest Caiaphas (voice) Mark Hamill King Herod (voice) Ava Sanger Mary Dickens (voice) Jim Cummings James the Greater / Pharisee Hillel (voice) Dee Bradley Baker Willa the Cat (voice) Fred Tatasciore Pharisee Eleazar (voice) James Arnold Taylor Melchior / Matthew / Thomas / Phillip / Young Jesus (voice) Vanessa Marshall Mary of Bethany / Adulteress (voice) Mick Wingert Gaspar / Pharisee Mahaliell (voice) Imari Williams Balthazar / Bartholomew (voice) Frank Todaro Gestas (voice)