Anna Faris Kate Sullivan Eugenio Derbez Leonardo Montenegro Eva Longoria Theresa John Hannah Colin Swoosie Kurtz Grace Mel Rodriguez Bobby Josh Segarra Jason Hannah Nordberg Emily Sullivan Alyvia Alyn Lind Olivia Sullivan Payton Lepinski Molly Sullivan Fernando Luján Papi Cecilia Suárez Magdalena Mariana Treviño Sofia Jesús Ochoa Vito Omar Chaparro Burro Adrián Uribe Burrito Edgar Vivar Gastroenterologist Per Graffman Captain Nils Hognestad First Mate Thomas Nicholson Crew Member Javier Lacroix Carlos - Cook Edwin Perez Dishwasher Garry Chalk Dr. Fletcher Morgan Brayton Nurse Darla Fay Receptionist Toby Hargrave Local Boat Mechanic Elizabeth Bowen Boat Mechanic's Wife Eric Keenleyside Elk Cove Sheriff Emily Maddison Amanda Cynthia Mendez Lucia Angie Larocque Genevieve Michael Karl Richards Rich Client Linda Pollard Female Mikado Performer David Mathews Male Mikado Performer Lia Farrelly-Hodge Jet Skier #1 Celeste Ziegler Jet Skier #2 Stephi Chin-Salvo Jet Skier #3 Tara Erica Moore Pretty Girl Ron Bottitta Soccer Commentator (voice) (uncredited)